Guitars have six strings and each string is tuned to a different note. Uke can be played without picks just fine; they're small; and the nylon strings are easy to play. What is the difference between a 12-string guitar and a mandolin? Most people would find the ukulele easier to learn than the mandolin. I say give it a shot, you can always … The Mandolin is plucked like a guitar while the violin is played using a bow. As such, you may be better off learning the mandolin if you’re particularly interested in the genres above. Willy has been teaching for over 20 years, and his students have ranged in age from young children to folks in their 80s. One of the most apparent differences between guitars and mandolins is that full-size guitars are typically much larger than mandolins. Each instrument would require you a bit of financial and time investment, so it would be wise to learn one instrument at a time. These differences can have a significant impact on which instrument is best for you to learn. What’s the Hardest Part of Learning to Play Ukulele? From the link above you can easily spend hours going through them all. Where it balances out is in the technique. There's a reason for that. Both are stringed instruments. Proper bridge placement is crucial to the sound of an instrument. I bought a $100 mandolin that functioned so poorly it wasn’t playable and ended up purchasing a Michael Kelly mandolin for ~$600 that worked great. Start with the uke first. Other strange ukuleles include Banjo ukuleles, electric ukuleles, and all sorts of stuff like that. A mando-guitar is a 6 string mandolin guitar hybrid instrument tuned like a guitar (EADGBE) except one octave higher so that it’s in the same tonal range as the Mandolin. Learning to coordinate two hands, one to finger the fretboard and the other to strum/pluck will apply to both instruments. Willy M. teaches mandolin, ukulele, and guitar lessons in Winston Salem, NC. Because it has fewer strings compared to many other stringed instruments such as the guitar and violin, reading tablature is definitely a lot easier. Most of the time the correct position will be just slightly behind the f-hole midpoints as shown in the mandolin photo above. You can also do simple street performances with one whereas with a uke that would be difficult just for the fact you really can't hear one. Plucks and fretted like a guitar, small-necked and tunes like a … I study two great sources of songs: ukulele-tabs.com and the ukulele teacher which have lots of contents dedicated for … It's cheaper, easier to play, easier to string up, lighter in weight and arguably more fun to play than the mandolin is. On the other hand, the mandolin has a floating bridge or a bridge that is not fixed to the instrument. If you place the bridge too high or too low, the instrument will not produce the sound you want. If you want something that's better as a songwriting instrument for recording at home, the ukulele is the clear winner. The bridge is the part of a stringed instrument that supports the strings and holds them above the neck of the instrument. You’re OK figuring out some things on your own as there aren’t as many learning resources for the mandolin. The fret board of the mandolin is smaller than the fret board of the guitar so it is easier for those with smaller hands and can be more difficult for those with larger hands. While interest in learning how to play the mandolin is not really that high, you can still learn how to play it fairly easily. When you begin to learn to play the ukulele, your first challenge is to exercise on a few chords that will allow you to learn your first songs. And even if you stick with a full-size guitar, you can make your guitar easier to play by: If you’ve decided to pursue guitar and want to learn more about which guitar is best for you, check out this buyer’s guide. In my experience, I’ve found fewer learning resources available for the mandolin than for the guitar. It's less expensive, easier to learn, less stressful on the hands, more forgiving to a beginner, and has a wide following. The above instrument is a Fender Ukulele '52. The acoustic guitar and ukulele are perhaps the most popular stringed instruments especially among aspiring musicians. The mandolin has various right and left hand techniques that you will also learn if you play guitar or banjo, yet they may be more prevalent in some cases. Differences Between The Mandolin and Ukulele … Some people just love the mandolin’s lighter, higher notes and sound. Furthermore, the frets of the mandolin are too narrow. When you remove the strings on a mandolin, the bridge can move or fall down. You may want to learn the mandolin if you prefer the higher pitch of the strings. So, ukelele may be a bit easier for the fretboard hand, because of the light action, and could be a gentler introduction for coordinating the two hands. Because bridge placement is so important, it’s a little bit more difficult to replace the strings on instruments with floating bridges which can be intimidating for beginners. And a mandolin. Ukuleles come in many shapes and sizes. Also, if you know how to play the mandolin, playing the guitar or the ukulele will be a piece of cake for you since they are less complicated. Ukulele: Pro – Ease of play. Your email address will not be published. Your email address will not be published. This part isn't as straightforward. In 2019 after having owned my Michael Kelly mandolin for over 10 years, I sold it on Ebay and purchased this Goldtone mando-guitar. If you want to learn the mandolin, then you should accustom your fingers in holding double strings. However, each pair of strings on 12-string guitars have one octave between them whereas mandolin string pairs are tuned to the exact same note. Also, smaller instruments like the mandolin have lighter gauge strings that are easier to press down. On the other hand. You travel frequently, you want to bring an instrument with you, and you appreciate the compactness of the mandolin and how well it travels. I studied the violin for many years, so it was easy to switch to the mandolin. It is relatively easy. They are (potentially, usually) tuned differently, yes. If you already play guitar, you will find the mandolin much easier to play. Ukulele is an Affordable Instrument Mandolins aren’t as popular as guitar, thus fewer are made, and the ones that are made are generally more expensive. You’re willing to spend more to invest in a quality instrument. As far as memorizing the notes, the mandolin has the advantage here. I'm 13, I've been practicing the violin since I was 8, and I'm still at it. If you've no idea where to set a bridge when installing new strings on a mandolin, you use those f-hole midpoints as a guide. Best ZOOM R8 tutorial bookhighly rated, get recording quick! Yes… and no. Another reason why you rather play the mandolin is that it has a bigger room for experimenting, and its sound is so mallow, which brings an old sense to it that never fails to make people stop and just listen to that beautiful sound. Still, your ukulele calluses should help you here. It's called a '52 because the thing is supposed to look sorta/kinda like a '52 Telecaster, but eh... not really. When you replace the strings on a guitar, you don’t have to worry about the bridge moving at all. Tuning an ukulele like a mandolin is fun and, as you mentioned, you don't have to learn new chord patterns etc. Ukuleles’ soft nylon strings are much kinder to the old fingers and, because there’s only four of them, you might find it easier to learn the chord shapes. Ukes are fun little things that remind you why you play guitar to begin with. 1. In general, the ukulele is going to be the easier instrument for most players to get a grasp on. On the other hand, the mandolin string pairs are slightly harder to pick with the right hand than the guitar. This can make learning mandolin more difficult than learning guitar. The ukulele is very easy to learn. Standard tuning for the mandolin is G-D-A-E which is the same as the tuning used for a violin or fiddle. The compact size of both instruments make them quite easy to bring along anywhere you wish to go. You can totally buy a mandolin if you want, but don't be surprised if you rarely take it out to actually play the thing. Mandolin is small, but yes, you're pressing down two strings with each finger, and it pretty much requires a flat-pick to get much volume. See a whole bunch of mandolins right here. Violin is a beautiful instrument, but its can be very difficult to learn. I thoroughly enjoy playing my mandolin and think it’s a beautiful instrument. You should most definitely learn the guitar along-side the uke. Required fields are marked *. The small size reduces wrist tension because the notes are reachable without stretching. Though 12-string guitars and mandolins both have strings tuned in pairs, the other differences between the instruments listed in this article still apply. Mandolins, on the other hand, have eight strings and each pair of strings are tuned to the exact same note. Your hands are large enough that you’re concerned you won’t be able to effectively play within the small frets of the mandolin. Taking your guitar to a repair shop and having them lower the action (reducing the distance between the strings and the neck). However, there are some challenges that some people have come across when it comes to learning to play the mandolin. One of the first things I wanted to know when I started playing the mandolin was how exactly these instruments differed. There are many reasons to learn and play the best ukuleles. Documenting What I'm Learning about Acoustic Guitar and Guitar Hybrids, on Guitar Vs. Mandolin: How They Differ & Which One to Learn, Guitar Vs. Violin: How They Differ & Which You Should Learn, Guitar-Like Instruments & Which You Might Consider Learning. As time passed and the instrument spread around Europe, it took on many names and various structural characteristics. The ukulele is easier to learn than the guitar and other stringed instruments like the mandolin. The notes of the open mandolin strings from thickest string (lowest note) to the thinnest string (highest note) are: GDAE (or really GGDDAAEE), (An acronym you can use to remember this is: Giant Dogs Ate Everyone.). Also, because mandolins are smaller, it can take more precision and man-hours to make a mandolin. I can now get that beautiful mandolin sound playing the same guitar licks and chords I play on my standard guitar. The appealing features of smaller instruments can be easily met in a guitar. When you want to know where to set the bridge, the f-hole midpoints are your guide. The original instrument was the mandore, which evolved in the fourteenth century from the lute. been learning to play, and I've toyed around with it on numerous occasions. I own multiple floating and fixed bridge instruments and I’m a little bit more nervous replacing the strings on my floating bridge instruments. So you can almost think of the mandolin as a fretted violin that you can strum like a guitar. If you want the choice made real easy for you, get a Kala brand uke. Should I take up the ukulele, mandolin or banjo? People try to learn and play the ukulele. And again, there are way more ukulele choices compared to mandolins. There are few similarities between violin and mandolin which is the reason some newbies find it hard to decide on which they should start learning first. However, people with tiny fingers might encounter problems when playing the mandolin. If you want to hear the difference in sound between the mandolin and the mando-guitar, check out the videos below where I play the beginning of Ode to a Butterfly on the mandolin and then on the mando-guitar. ... Oh! The styles of music that mandolin is used for require higher degrees of skill. Now back to learning the basics. I think the mandolin is the easiest to play, but that’s my personal preference. We’ll discuss these differences and which instrument is best for you to learn in light of these differences in the following sections. So after much deliberation, I sold my mandolin, purchased the goldtone mando-guitar, and have never once regretted the decision. As art and fashion always repeat themselves, similarly the fashion of ukulele has not faded away yet. The strings are steel, which are a bit rougher on the fingers than the nylon strings used with a ukulele. It's why all the kiddies these days chose the uke rather than the mandolin. Modern mandolins originated in Naples, Italy in the 3rd quarter of the 18th century. Because the ukulele and mandolin are set up differently, their chords will be played in different ways. Fit . If you play guitar now and are considering the ukulele or mandolin as your next stringed instrument, one choice is better than the other. Unfortunately, the opposite is true for mandolins. As long as you approach this learning process from a broad, open-minded point of view, YES. I show the Ukulele '52 for a reason which I'll explain in a moment. Why? If that’s you, then the mandolin might be the instrument for you to pursue. On most guitars, the bridge is fixed or immovable. A Mandolin has 8 strings, a ukulele usually has 4 strings. Start with the uke first. Third, it's a more difficult instrument to play that requires more finger strength. Once the novelty of a mandolin wears off, you may find it difficult if not impossible to use it for songwriting. 5 minutes is enough to do so. In short, the guitar is probably a better instrument choice for you if many of the following are true: If this is you, check out my buyer’s guide to acoustic guitars here. What I really like about mine is the fact that they play just like my mandolin but sound quite different tonally. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. 10 Reasons Why You Should Learn to Play the Mandolin. So, how hard is it to play the ukulele? One great aspect of learning the guitar is that, because it’s so popular, you can purchase a fantastic beginner guitar for not that much money. You want to be able to learn from an abundance of learning resources. This isn’t the only downside to the mandolin due to its lesser popularity than guitar. The main differences with the mandolin would be: The tuning is pretty different, so one will need to learn some new chord shapes. In general, you should expect to spend between $50 and $150 on your first ukulele, and take the time to look for a trusted brand. The beginner guitar I recommend in my acoustic guitar buyer’s guide is the Jasmine S35 which is just under $100. I think the mechanics of playing the mandolin may be slightly easier than the mechanics of playing the guitar (but not as easy as the ukulele). Author has 298 answers and 149.2K answer views. For that reason, you will need so much practice to have a presentable skills in playing mandolin. I especially recommend the ukulele to guitar players who feel they're in a rut and want something that sparks songwriting creativity for cheap. – Since the ukulele strings are a bit wider apart than on a guitar, it makes it easier for the right hand in regards to picking individual strings. However, I think the guitar is better-suited for most beginners who are deciding which instrument to play first. The mandolin has a much more intuitive tuning. You could buy one and brag that you own a "real" Fender '52 and you technically wouldn't be lying. And here’s the same tune on the mando-guitar (note the subtle difference in their sounds): I hope I haven’t discouraged you from learning the mandolin. Like we said, it doesn’t take long to learn the ukulele. If you can form simple chords, and you can strum, you can start playing songs you like to sing! You understand you may need to get your instrument setup from time to time with a luthier because replacing the strings and making sure the bridge is in its proper place are more tedious on the mandolin than on the guitar. If case you're wondering, yes this also applies to acoustic 6-string guitars with non-permanent mount bridges, violins and pretty much any other stringed instrument that has f-holes on it. Learn more about Willy here! So it has many of the benefits of both the mandolin and the guitar. The terms tremolo, cross-picking and chops should ring a bell for a seasoned mandolin player. First, it's usually more expensive than a uke. However, I think that learning the guitar or mando-guitar is ultimately easier because there are more learning resources available for the guitar than for the mandolin. You love the tonal range of the mandolin and are interested in bluegrass, country, folk, and other genres that incorporate the mandolin. Is mandolin easier to learn than guitar? Thus, mandolins are usually more expensive than guitars of similar quality. You will learn about the different parts of the ukulele, how to tune the ukulele, chord formation, and strumming. live street performance), the mandolin is the winner, no question. I think Fender calls it a '52 as more of a joke than anything. It simply stays in place as you restring the guitar. People are easily drawn to music and the arts. Though more and more learning resources are published for both instruments every day, guitar’s popularity means there are simply more resources available for those learning guitar. Why one Should Learn and Play the Best Ukuleles. Many adults enjoy smaller guitars with fret-boards that are easier to maneuver like the Martin LX1E or the Taylor GS Mini! I started playing the mandolin 4 years after I started learning the guitar (and I’ve played both instruments for over a decade). On the other hand, learning scales and the names of notes is much easier when it comes to playing the mandolin. It just needs to sit wherever the intonation of the strings sounds best to your ears. If you want to maintain your instrument with ease by yourself, you are better suited learning the guitar. Fourth, there's not nearly as much choice with mandolins as there is with ukes. However, there are other more legitimate reasons the mandolin might be a better instrument for you. Is mandolin easier to learn than guitar? The Mandolin requires more intuition in tuning, and the form of music it plays also calls for a higher degree of expertise. It's cheaper, easier to play, easier to string up, lighter in weight and arguably more fun to play than the mandolin is. Therefore, if you have a large set of fingers, then that's a big problem. The entire reason the mandolin is louder is because it's more resonant, uses double the strings of a uke and also uses steel strings. And again, there are way more ukulele choices compared to mandolins. The sound that is produced by the mandolin is very different when compared to its close relative guitar. However, I wouldn’t recommend spending anything less than this amount on an entry level mandolin. Banjo would require fingerpicking, as you've mentioned, and they tend to be longer than both mandolin and uke. They're built right. The G string on the ukulele is a thin-gauge string. If the bridge is set too far forward or too far back, you'll never get the thing in tune correctly. In fact, when it’s boiled down to its simplest form, there really are only two things you need to learn to play the ukulele: chord formation and strumming. Brands like Lanikai and Cordoba are known for their relatively inexpensive instruments for those who are entering their first round of ukulele basics. (This is one of the aspects of the mandolin that drew me to it.). As I mentioned above, the mandolin’s open tuning is higher than the guitars and can thus reach higher notes than the guitar. The notes of the open guitar strings from the thickest string (lowest note) to the thinnest string (highest note) are: EADGBE, (An acronym you can use to remember this is: Every Amateur Does Get Better Eventually.). Does the bridge need to sit exactly where the f-hole midpoints are? ‘You can always learn the mandolin after. So if you’re on a tight budget, guitar is a better choice than mandolin. I already play the violin and guitar ... My sister has a mandolin that she's. Mandolin Chords Every Beginner Should Know 3rd December 2020 by Ged Richardson When you set out to learn the mandolin, there are some basic chords you need to know. Mandolins are actually tuned the same way a violin is tuned (except that mandolins have 4 pairs of strings and violins have 4 single strings). So how are guitars and mandolins different? You'll notice nearly every single model gets glowingly positive reviews. ... attempting to learn said instrument will obviously shred my fingers beyond their already numb state. For children or those with smaller hands, a smaller fret board like a mandolin’s make playing the instrument generally easier. From the link above you can easily spend hours going through them all. There is much to choose from when looking at these three great cigars made for cigar loungers. The mandolin has more strings than the guitar but the strings are tuned in pairs which should make the left-hand fingering role easier than on the guitar. This makes the mandolin and other smaller instruments appealing to many for a variety of reasons. One big advantage the mandolin has over the uke is that it's a far better instrument for live performances. However, the mandolin is most often played in the above-mentioned genres. It is a not an easy task. One option for tuning the ukulele like a mandolin … No. The mandolin is an easy instrument to learn. The mandolin has more strings than the guitar but the strings are tuned in pairs which should make the left-hand fingering role easier than on the guitar. See a whole bunch of mandolins right here, Fender Player Lead II is awful (get the III instead), How my guitars handled The Great Texas Freeze of 2021, All guitar companies need to start listing 1st and 12th fret measurements, BEAD tuning for bass, the easiest way for tuning down, Best electric guitars to play with fingers, Best acoustic guitar for under $500 might be the Guild DS-240. The Torpedo was a big hit with the crowd and as a fan of the Corona Cigar company it was refreshing … Its soft nylon strings are gentler on your fingertips and don't create finger pain like guitars do. Intonation. The ukulele originated in the 19th century as a Hawaiian interpretation of a small guitar-like instrument brought by Portuguese immigra… This is something that can be quite delayed on guitar if the learner is struggling to get their fingers around the chords in the first place. I think the mechanics of playing the mandolin may be slightly easier than the mechanics of playing the guitar (but not as easy as the ukulele). On fixed bridge instruments like the guitar, a beginner can quickly and easily replace the strings and otherwise maintain the instrument. Your hands are small enough that you’re concerned you won’t be able to effectively play the guitar and are looking for a smaller instrument. This instrument provides a sound and note range similar to that of a mandolin with the number of strings and tuning of a guitar so that a guitarist can play it just like a guitar but get a mandolin sound from it. And that includes the cost it takes to restring one. What instruments to play on ukulele – learn to learn. Tip on mandolins: If you decide to get a mandolin and it has a bridge that isn't permanently mounted (meaning it comes loose when you take the strings off,) the general rule of thumb is to line it up either at or close to the middle of the f-holes. Second, it's not all that good as a songwriting instrument. Combined with this, it will take quite a bit more time to sound presentable on a mandolin. If not, the guitar might be the better instrument for you to pursue. If you like the idea of busking (i.e. The mando-guitar’s body closely resembles the size and shape of a mandolin. Because the mandolin is tuned like a violin, it makes the instrument well-suited for genres that are popular for the violin as well like: Of course, you will find the mandolin in many more musical genres than just those listed above. Though both of these facts are true about smaller instruments like the mandolin, this doesn’t necessarily mean you should play mandolin instead of guitar. Agreed, the ukulele fits your stated description better. Less than full-size guitars aren’t just for children. But before you buy that instrument, check out the next section to see if the mando-guitar is a better fit than the mandolin. This means you’re not going to be able to put down a ukulele, pick up a mandolin and start strumming (or vice versa). I love the mandolin sound but always felt overwhelmed by the hurdle of learning a new instrument and as such didn’t play my mandolin as often as I would have liked. If you still can’t decide between the guitar and the mandolin, you might consider getting a mando-guitar. The main difference between the mandolin and violin is the way that they are played. You want to play in a variety of genres and styles and might feel limited by the mandolin’s sound and range. 12-string guitars have 12 strings tuned in pairs like the mandolin. 1. A mandolin is acoustically much louder and from that can be picked up by microphones much easier. On the other hand, the mandolin might be a better choice for you if many of the following are true: If you think this sounds like you, this mandolin could be a good starter instrument for you. If you look at each f-hole, you'll see the middle has a "pointer" of sorts. The C string is the lowest and thickest string on the ukulele.